Behr Vs Sherwin Williams Deck Stain (Ultimate Guide)

You want something that will protect your deck wood, but you also don’t want it to be too heavy or dark. Plus, you want it to last. Behr and Sherwin-Williams paints are two of the most popular brands of deck stains, but they both have their pros and cons.

Deck stains are designed to protect your deck from the elements and keep it looking good for years. But with so many different brands and types of stains on the market, it can be hard to know which one is right for you.

We’ve compared Behr vs Sherwin Williams deck stains so that you can make an informed decision about which one is right for you. Also, read Behr Swiss Coffee vs Benjamin Moore Swiss Coffee if you are confused about choosing the right type of white paint for your home.

Sherwin Williams Deck Stain
Sherwin Williams Deck Stain

What Are the Differences In Between Behr Vs Sherwin Williams Deck Stain?

It’s no secret that a deck can be a great addition to any home. Not only does it provide a wonderful space for entertaining and relaxing, but it can also add value to your property.

Of course, to enjoy your deck for years to come, it’s important to choose the right deck stain.

So, what are the key differences between these two products?

1. Material Properties

When choosing a deck stain, it’s important to consider the material properties of the stain. Behr deck stains are made from durable acrylic resin, while Sherwin Williams deck stains are oil-based.

Acrylic resins are more resistant to fading and cracking, making them a good choice for decks with a lot of sun and foot traffic. Oil-based stains provide deeper penetration into the wood, making them ideal for older decks or decks that are exposed to harsh weather conditions.

2. Appearance

When it comes to appearance, Behr stains tend to be opaquer, while Sherwin Williams stains are more transparent. This means that Behr stains will cover up imperfections in your deck more effectively, while Sherwin Williams stains will allow the grain of your wood to show through.

Behr paint also offers a wider range of colors than Sherwin-Williams paint, so you’re more likely to find the perfect shade for your project. Plus, Behr stains come in both semi-solid and solid formulas, giving you more control over the final look of your deck.

3. Coverage Area

It is an important consideration when selecting a deck stain. Behr and Sherwin-Williams offer different coverage areas.

Behr states that its deck stains will cover between 250 to 400 square feet per gallon, while Sherwin Williams claims its deck stains will cover 400 square feet per gallon. This means that, for comparable coverage areas, Behr paint will require more gallons of deck stain than Sherwin Williams paint.

This is something to keep in mind when budgeting for a project. In addition, it is worth noting that the coverage areas listed by the manufacturers are theoretical maximums. In practice, actual coverage may be less depending on factors such as the porosity of the wood and the application method.

4. UV Protection

Deck stain from Behr contains a UV blocker that helps to prevent fading, while Sherwin Williams does not mention UV protection in their maximum product description. As a result, Behr deck stain is likely to last longer than Sherwin Williams before it needs to be reapplied.

When choosing a deck stain, be sure to consider the level of UV protection that you need. If you live in an area with strong sunlight, Behr paint may be the better option. However, if you are less concerned about fading, Sherwin Williams paint may be a better fit for your needs.

Behr Deck Stain(Brown)

5. Durability

When it comes to Behr, you can expect more durability than with Sherwin Williams. This is because Behr uses a higher-quality resin that is more resistant to wear and tear. As a result, Behr decks will last longer before needing to be refinished.

However, Sherwin Williams does have one advantage over Behr: it is easier to apply. This is because Sherwin Williams uses a lower-viscosity resin that penetrates the wood better. As a result, you won’t need to spend as much time or effort to stain your Sherwin-Williams deck.

6. VOC Content

There are a few things to consider when choosing a deck stain, including the VOC content. VOCs, or volatile organic compounds, are released into the air and can harm human health. The higher the VOC content, the more harmful the product is.

Regarding deck stains, Behr and Sherwin Williams have different VOC levels. Behr paint has a VOC level of 100 grams/liter, while Sherwin-Williams paint has a VOC level of fewer than 250 grams/liter.

This means that Sherwin-Williams paint is more harmful to human health than Behr paint. When choosing a deck stain, it is important to consider the VOC content to choose the safest option for your family.

Comparison Table of Behr and Sherwin Williams Deck Staining Paints:

FactorBehr Deck StainSherwin Williams Deck Stain
Material PropertiesAcrylic resinOil-based
AppearanceOpaquerMore transparent
Coverage Area250 to 400 Sq. Ft./gallon400 Sq. Ft./gallon
UV ProtectionVery GoodMax paint not mentioned.
VOC Content100 grams/liter250 grams/liter

What Are the Similarities In Between Behr and Sherwin Williams Deck Stain?

Now that we’ve looked at the key differences between Behr and Sherwin Williams deck stains let’s take a moment to consider the similarities.

Quality: Both Behr and Sherwin Williams offer premium deck stains that protect your deck from the weather. If you choose either of these brands, you can expect a durable and long-lasting finish.

Application Method: Both Behr and Sherwin Williams deck stains can be applied with a brush, roller, or sprayer. As a result, you can use either brand of paint, regardless of how you want to apply it.

Weatherproofing: Both paints are designed to withstand the elements. So, regardless of your local weather conditions, you can use any paint brand.

Color Selection: Each brand offers many colors to choose from. The result is that deck stains are available in a wide range of colors to match any decor.

Dry Time: Both Behr and Sherwin Williams deck stains have a dry time of 24 hours. This means that you can use your deck shortly after applying the paint.

What Is the Best Color Stain for A Deck?

When choosing a color for your deck stain, there are a few factors to consider.

First, think about what you want to achieve. Do you want a natural look that blends in with your yard or a bolder color that will make your deck stand out?

Once you’ve decided on the overall tone, you’ll need to choose between a solid stain and a semi-transparent stain. Solid stains provide more coverage and can help to conceal damage or wear and tear. Semi-transparent stains provide some coverage while allowing the wood grain to show through.

Finally, consider the color palette of your home. You may want to choose a color that complements the siding or trim of your house.

Sherwin Williams Deck Stain (Brown)

In general, Browns, Blues, Grays, Naturals, and Reds are popular choices for deck stains. And Behr and Sherwin Williams both offer a wide range of colors in each of these categories.

How to Apply Behr or Sherwin Williams Deck Stain?

Once you’ve chosen the right color, it’s time to apply your deck stain.

The first step is to clean your deck with a power washer or hose attachment. This will remove any dirt, debris, or mold that has accumulated on your deck.

Next, you’ll need to sand your deck. This will help the stain to penetrate the wood and achieve a better finish.

Once your deck is clean and sanded, it’s time to apply the stain. You can use a brush, roller, or sprayer to apply the stain. Then, let the stain dry for 24 hours before using your deck.

Finally, enjoy your newly stained deck.

Behr Deck Stain
Applying Behr Deck Stain

Is It Better to Stain a Deck Light or Dark?

When it comes to staining a deck, many homeowners wonder if it is better to go with a light or dark color. The truth is that both have their benefits, ultimately due to personal preference.

One advantage of choosing a darker stain is that it can help to resist fading from UV rays. If you plan on spending a lot of time outdoors, this may be the best option for you. However, keep in mind that dark stains will require more frequent reapplication than light stains.

Another option is to choose a transparent stain or sealer. These can also prevent sun damage to your deck but will need to be reapplied more often than a solid stain. Ultimately, deciding which color to choose is up to you and should be based on your personal preferences and needs.

You can choose from both Behr and Sherwin Williams light and dark stains in a variety of colors. So, you’re sure to find the perfect option for your deck.


After taking a closer look, it’s clear that both Behr and Sherwin Williams offer high-quality deck stains. Each brand offers a wide range of colors to choose from, as well as different application methods.

So, when it comes to choosing the ideal deck stain, the decision is ultimately up to you. Consider the overall look you want to achieve and the amount of upkeep you’re willing to do. Then, pick the color that best suits your needs. Just remember, both Behr and Sherwin Williams offer great options, so you can’t go wrong.