Charcoal Charm: Benjamin Moore Graphite vs Wrought Iron Comparison

When it comes to choosing the right shade of charcoal gray for your interior space, Benjamin Moore Graphite vs. Wrought Iron is often the first name that come to mind. These two paint colors have a classic and stylish look that can make any room feel better.

Graphite vs Wrought Iron
Benjamin Moore Graphite vs Wrought Iron undertones.

In this article, we will discuss in depth the differences and similarities between Benjamin Moore Graphite and Wrought Iron, as well as which is better for your home decor.

Benjamin Moore Graphite: A Contemporary Classic

Benjamin Moore Graphite, also known as 1603, is a color that effortlessly blends modern aesthetics with timeless elegance. This rich charcoal gray has a lot of depth and complexity, making it an excellent choice for creating a dramatic and moody atmosphere in your living space. The color’s undertones play a crucial role in its overall appearance – Graphite tends to lean slightly toward blue, adding a cooler undertone that can complement various decor styles.

Benjamin Moore Graphite
Benjamin Moore Graphite. Image from @KelseyBarrett

One of the standout features of Benjamin Moore Graphite is its ability to adapt to different lighting conditions. Whether your room is filled with natural light or illuminated by warm artificial lighting, it is a versatile choice for many places in your home.


  • Neutral undertone
  • Lighter than Wrought Iron
  • More durable than Wrought Iron


  • It can appear dull in some lighting conditions

Benjamin Moore Wrought Iron: The Bold Charcoal

Benjamin Moore’s Wrought Iron, also known as 2124-10, is a bold statement in the world of deep charcoals. This paint color gives off confidence and power and immediately draws attention to any room. Wrought Iron is more of a true neutral gray with hints of deep brown. This makes it feel earthy and grounded, which works well with modern and rustic interior designs. You can read Alabaster vs Origami White to see whether they can be perfect choice for you.

Benjamin Moore Wrought Iron
Benjamin Moore Wrought Iron on the walls & the island.

The richness of Wrought Iron adds depth to walls, bringing architectural details and creating a cozy also refined ambiance. Its distinct depth becomes more noticeable in areas with sufficient natural light, revealing a multi-dimensional, attractive, and sophisticated appearance.


  • Hints of blue undertone
  • It can appear more dramatic than Graphite
  • More versatile than Graphite


  • Darker than Graphite
  • Not as durable as Graphite

Graphite and Wrought Iron: Know The Differences

These colors may look the same, but they have different characteristics. Here are some of them:

1.   Undertones:

  • Graphite: Cooler undertones with a subtle touch of blue, adding a contemporary feel.
  • Wrought Iron: A deeper neutral base with hints of brown offers a balanced and versatile look.

2.   Lighting Adaptability:

  • Graphite: Adapts well to different lighting conditions, maintaining its allure.
  • Wrought Iron: Displays multi-dimensional depth, particularly in areas with abundant natural light.

3.   Mood and Atmosphere:

  • Graphite: Creates a moody and dramatic atmosphere, perfect for intimate spaces.
  • Wrought Iron: Evokes confidence and strength, making a bold statement in any room.

4.   Pairing with Decor:

Benjamin Moore Graphite:

  • Complement with metallic accents like brushed nickel or chrome for a contemporary edge.
  • Enhance the cool undertones with crisp white trims for a sharp contrast.
  • Incorporate textured fabrics and rugs to warm and balance the cool tones.

Wrought Iron:

  • Pair with earthy tones such as warm browns, deep greens, or terracotta for a harmonious look.
  • Contrast with light-colored furniture and accessories to create a striking visual impact.
  • Integrate natural materials like exposed wood and stone to enhance the rustic charm.


Benjamin moore Graphite vs Wrought Iron on the kitchen cabinets
Benjamin moore Graphite vs Wrought Iron on the kitchen cabinets and island.

Table of Differences:

SpecificationBenjamin Moore GraphiteBenjamin Moore Wrought Iron
LRV (Light Reflectance Value)7.598.17
RGB ValuesR: 68, G: 70, B: 71R: 73, G: 74, B: 75
HEX Codes#444647#494A4B
AtmosphereMoody, sophisticatedStrong, confident, and grounded
Room ApplicationsBedrooms, study, cozy spacesLiving rooms, dining rooms, hallways
Room Size ImpactCreates a cozy and intimate feel in larger spacesAdds coziness and depth to larger rooms
Accent ColorsPairs beautifully with muted blues and greensEnhances earthy tones like deep greens
UndertonesCooler undertones with a touch of blueDeeper neutral base with hints of brown
Suitable StylesContemporary, modernModern, Rustic

Color Combinations

Pairing colors effectively can significantly impact the overall look and feel of a space. Here are a few color combinations that work well with both Graphite and Wrought Iron, helping you create a visually appealing interior:

Color Combinations with Graphite:

  1. Graphite and Crisp White: Enhance the modern feel of Graphite by pairing it with crisp white trim and accents. This classic combination creates a clean and sophisticated look.
  2. Graphite and Mustard Yellow: Add a pop of vibrant energy by combining Graphite with mustard yellow accents or furnishings. This pairing balances warmth and depth.
  3. Graphite and Teal: Consider incorporating teal accents for a touch of boldness. Teal’s blue-green tones contrast nicely with Graphite’s cooler undertones.

Color Combinations with Wrought Iron:

  1. Wrought Iron and Soft Beige: Create a warm and inviting space by pairing Wrought Iron with soft beige or light taupe. This combination offers a cozy yet elegant atmosphere.
  2. Wrought Iron and Sage Green: Connect with nature by introducing sage green accents. This pairing brings a refreshing and tranquil vibe to your room.
  3. Wrought Iron and Rich Burgundy:  Add a sense of richness and depth by combining Wrought Iron with deep burgundy or wine-colored elements. This combination exudes sophistication.

Remember, balancing contrasting and complementary colors is key to successful color pairing. Consider the mood you want to create and the existing elements in your space, such as furniture, textiles, and accessories.

Choosing Between Graphite and Wrought Iron:

Choosing between these colors ultimately depends on your preferences, the mood you want to create in your space, and the existing decor and lighting in the room. Let’s break down some considerations to help you make an informed decision:

Benjamin moore Graphite vs Wrought Iron on doors
These doors beautifully painted with Benjamin moore graphite and wrought iron.

1.   Mood and Atmosphere:

  • Graphite: If you’re aiming for a moody and dramatic ambiance, especially in intimate spaces like bedrooms or cozy reading nooks, Graphite’s cooler undertones and adaptability to various lighting conditions make it an excellent choice.
    • Wrought Iron: If you want a bold and confident statement with a hint of rustic charm, Wrought Iron’s deep, neutral base and multi-dimensional appearance can add strength and character to your room.

2.   Decor Style:

  • Graphite: Works well in contemporary or modern decor. It pairs beautifully with metallic accents, crisp white trims, and textured fabrics to create a balanced and visually appealing environment.
    • Wrought Iron: Complements both modern and rustic design aesthetics. It pairs harmoniously with earthy tones, light-colored furniture, and natural materials to enhance the room’s charm.

3.   Natural Lighting:

  • Graphite: Adapts well to different lighting conditions, maintaining its allure and depth. It can work in both well-lit and dimly-lit spaces.
    • Wrought Iron: Shines in areas with ample natural light, revealing its multi-dimensional appearance. Consider this if your room receives a lot of sunlight.

4.   Room Size:

  • Graphite: Due to its cooler undertones, Graphite can create a visually cozy and intimate atmosphere in larger spaces, making them feel more inviting.
    • Wrought Iron: The depth of Wrought Iron can add a sense of coziness to larger rooms, making them feel more intimate and comfortable.

5.   Get samples and test them out:

  • The best way to decide which dark charcoal paint color is right for you is to get samples and test them in your home. Apply the samples to different surfaces in your home to see how they look in different lighting conditions. Once you have seen both colors in person, you will be able to decide which one is the best fit for your needs.

No matter which color you choose, dark charcoal paint can add a touch of sophistication and style to your home.

Final words:

Benjamin Moore Graphite and Wrought Iron offer distinct characteristics that can elevate your home decor. Whether you opt for the modern allure of Graphite or the commanding presence of Wrought Iron, your choice will undoubtedly contribute to a captivating and inviting living space that reflects your unique style and personality.